Book chat: Should we keep negative opinions to ourselves?

Today, I want to discuss whether people can express their negative opinions. In my very first book chat, I discuss whether fans are allowed to be critical. So this book chat really stems from that, but I will focus on people who clearly dislike – or even hate – a book (series).

Example 1: A Court of Thorns and Roses and Throne of Glass

Anyone who is active on social media, will have noticed all the drama surrounding the Empire of Storms release. Some people received an early copy and weren’t happy at all with what they read.

People who express their negative opinions, have been called ‘petty’, ‘problematic’ … and ‘should just read what makes them happy and shut up about what they hate’. Don’t they realise that some people put a lot of time and money into that series? If they don’t like it, they have the right to be disappointed and express their opinions. Just because you like it, doesn’t mean everyone else will. That is literally impossible.

I understand why people don’t like seeing negative reviews on their favourite books and series. I have been there. I have de-friended people on Goodreads because they hated my favourite books and I really disagreed with them. But, I still allow them to express their opinion. I would never write a comment on their review saying they are wrong, they don’t appreciate good writing… Whenever people say that to me, I will probably only dislike the book more. I don’t think anyone has ever read those comments and thought: “Oh, you know what, they are right. I love the book now”. I actually consider writing comments like that petty, not disliking a book and being vocal about it.

There are actually readers who have cancelled their pre-orders because of the spoilers they have read. I think it is completely okay to dislike something you have not read yourself. Spoilers can give you an idea of whether or not you will like it. Readers shouldn’t ‘suffer’ reading through something they know they won’t like, just to please others.

And that is exactly the reason why I won’t continue Sarah J. Maas’ series. I have only read the first books in both series and The Assassin’s Blade. But, based on what I have heard, I will not like how it continues. I don’t like the idea of an author completely destroying one character in order for readers to fall in love with another. I think that’s a cheap thing to do. To be clear, I based my opinion on what fans have said as well, not only haters.

The book community should not be all moonlight and roses. I think it can learn a lot from those negative opinions. Even if you love Sarah J. Maas’ work, you have to admit that they are filled with straight white people. So it’s a very good thing people are vocal about this. While I don’t like shipping drama, people should be honest about their pairings and admit it is problematic or even abusive if that’s the case. Actually, whenever people talk about her series, they only talk about the romance. And because I am tired of reading about straight couples, I’m not planning on continuing her series.

So yes, I think it’s okay to dislike something you have not actually read yourself. However, don’t rate before you read! Don’t give a book one star because you know you’ll hate it. But also, don’t rate a book five stars because you know you’ll love it! Even if I have read 75% of a book, I don’t rate it when I DNF it.

I actually wrote a ‘review‘ on A Court of Mist and Fury, explaining why I wouldn’t read it. And I received lots of hateful reactions. So, yes, people who love something, can be very nasty as well. Let’s not pretend as if it’s a one way street.

It is clear that I am advocate of expressing your opinions, both positive and negative. However, I do not think it is okay to attack others, to disagree with others on their own post/social media, to threaten the author… And I can’t believe that even has to be said.

example 2: Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child was the very first book I gave a one star rating. I am a huge Harry Potter fan, but that script completely butchered all of the characters and the plot was all over the place. It was actually hilariously awful: I couldn’t take it seriously, even though the play was obviously trying to be.

I won’t go into detail, but you can read why I hated it here. In my first book chat, I came to the conclusion that people can critique their favourite books and still be as much as a fan as others. I still consider myself a Harry Potter fan, even though I hated Cursed Child. As usual when someone expresses a negative opinion, I received hateful messages. Saying I am not a true fan because I didn’t rate something written by J.K. Rowling five stars (newsflash: it wasn’t even written by her), I shouldn’t judge the script without watching the play… Reactions like these are the reason why people are afraid to be honest. Right now, I don’t really care anymore when people say I am not a ‘real’ fan, because I know that’s not true. But a couple of months ago, it would have hurt my feelings.

Example 3: shadybooktweets

Shadybooktweets is a Twitter account where people can anonymously share their opinions on books. I know quite a few people who have blocked that page because they think people should stop wasting their energy on negativity. I follow @shadybooktweets and while I am not going to pretend all confessions are acceptable, a lot mention diversity (POC, LGBT…) and I obviously support that, because books still lack this.

However, as usual, there is some shipping drama, back and forth arguments… And that’s definitely its downside. But I cannot help supporting a platform that also allows people to be honest that books, even their favourites, lack diversity. And maybe the people who blocked the Twitter page don’t want to admit that.

Just to be clear: I do not agree with every confession posted there. Some are quite nasty (e.g. attacking certain booktubers) and I do not condone that. But I like the idea of a place where people can express their (negative) opinions. And since people are afraid of expressing them openly – out of fear of being attack – they have to turn to that account. For the record: I have never posted a confession there and I don’t plan to. I just like to read them, even though I strongly disagree with some.

So, should we keep our negative opinions to ourselves?

No, we shouldn’t! If people are allowed to constantly praise books, people should be allowed to dislike it as well. Negativity does not necessarily have to be a bad thing.

Nevertheless, people should still be civil (though I could say the same to people who love something) and not attack others or the author.

What is your opinion on this? I am curious to read your thoughts because there are so many different opinions when it comes to this topic. Please know that this is my own opinion and I am not attacking anyone.



4 thoughts on “Book chat: Should we keep negative opinions to ourselves?

  1. norahsumner says:

    I feel the same way about Sarah J. Maas’s series, only read the first book in Throne of Glass, but I’ve read all the spoilers and decided not to continue. But I didn’t particularly liked the first book anyway.

    Everyone should say what they want to say. I’ve given books with amazing ratings a one star review and vice-versa, and I have no problem with people disliking books that I loved. Everyone has a different way of understanding and connecting with a book, so it’s normal to have different opinions.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Chelsea ϟ romweasley says:

      I read the novellas and Throne of Glass and thought they were okay, but I didn’t understand the hype. I actually own Crown of Midnight, but I’ll probably never read it.

      I completely agree with you! I personally enjoy writing negative reviews much more than positive ones. After all, that’s what social media are for: to express your own thoughts. So I don’t understand why some people want to silence others who say something negative. Perhaps they take it personally. But disliking a book doesn’t mean you dislike the people who do like it.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Minni Mouse says:

    Great review! You’ve stated your points quite well! πŸ™‚

    I know that this statement is callous and people disagree, but it’s also “just a book” and “just a review.” I don’t mean to downplay the impact that books and entertainment have on us — I mean that at the end of the days, livelihoods aren’t directly threatened as an immediate result of a book review.

    If people want to cancel their pre-orders, wrote a glowing review, or give a scathing review before they’ve even read the book, it’s still just one book and just one rating. Sarah J. Maas and J.K. Rowling have enough of an audience that their works won’t suffer if one or 100 people write scathing reviews. I’m with you – I don’t believe it makes sense to rate a book and write a review on a book you haven’t read (seems lIke a book forum or private message thread is more appropriate for that) but I think one reason people do that is because it’s the most visible way to discuss the topic…and it draws traffic to their account. I also have seen my own Goodreads friends actively pick/reinvigorate fights by either contributing to other people’s posts or “bumping” their current review. To me, that’s petty. To me, their statements are childish as well.

    But to the people that either try to defend or “make them see reason,” I say don’t bother. Most of the comments in these threads are emotional responses and trust me – there’s no arguing with emotional responses. When emotion and passion are involved, you’re more likely to tangent on points that aren’t even relevant to the original conversation and you’re more likely to unfairly generalize a population segment, e.g. “Everyone who likes Throne of Glass is racist!”

    So I say let them be. These controversies and nonsensical rants are indicative of larger issues that aren’t limited to book reviews. They extend to sports, entertainment, politics, international affairs, office workplace, and family dynamics. You’re never going to make someone “see the light of day” by arguing with someone on Goodreads; that’s something only a broad life experience can teach.


  3. debbieslibrary says:

    This is a great discussion point! And I agree with you, if you have negative thoughts on a book you have the right to say that, just as much as the people who are telling how much they love a book.
    But I do think, when you are sharing your negative thoughts on a book or anything, you have to stay respectful, you can say something negative but in a nice way. The writer has worked hours upon hours, writing that book, have some respect for that. And just because you don’t like something, doesn’t mean that everybody won’t like it, so have respect for the ones who love the book or the ones who dislike a book you like.
    I also think you can’t hate/dislike everything in a book, there has to be something you enjoyed, even if it was just one scene. Just like you can’t love everything in a book, I have given a 5 stars to a book, but still disagreed on two points.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s